I dunno... the Marineland literature says that if the bio-wheel has trouble turning, that's ok, but it doesn't mention anything about a clicking noise. I might email them and see what they think. If it's really bothering you though, I'm remember reading about about some sort of bushing that the bio-wheel turns on that you should be able to replace. Again, I'm just making a guess, but that's probably what's making the noise, since that's what the bio-wheel turns on. ?