I have 2 oscars in a 100 gal. tank and they fight from time to time. What I've been told about mine was they are both probably males and are fighting for who's in charge. As they get older and bigger, they are less tolerant of another oscar in the tank and fight. Keep a close eye on the fighting, and if they get too destructive where one has serious battle wounds, you may have to put that separator in there or remove one from the tank.