just wondering

no.1chuy

Large Fish
May 22, 2009
272
0
0
Las Vegas
#1
so i've been doing some reading about swordtails and from what i've read you cant get a hi-fin swordtail from breeding two normal fin swordtails even if they where born from hi-fin parents so my question is where did the hi-fin swordtail come from? i dont know if my question makes sense
 

no.1chuy

Large Fish
May 22, 2009
272
0
0
Las Vegas
#2
what about the lyretail can you get lyre swordtails from breeding two regular swordtails or is that not possible because they dont have the "lyre" gene? is there even a lyre gene at all? and if getting lyres from regular swordtails isnt possible where did they come from?
 

Newman

Elite Fish
Sep 22, 2009
4,668
0
0
Northern NJ
#4
The original lyre and hifin genes are, as with all abnormal genes not normally found in the wild (natural selection. would a hifin or lyre swordtail have better survival chances in the wild? NOT from predators but maybe in sexual selection), nothing more than mutations. In a domesticated environment, people breed a lot, so the rate of such mutations showin up are greater. Then they preform selective breeding for whatever traits they want, such as the lyre and hifin.

To be noted: almost all swordtail variations have already been discovered and bred for.
 

Feb 27, 2009
4,395
0
36
#8
Yea i read that article around a week ago...someone must hav been reeeealy bored to concider artificial ensemination with swordtails lol...
Artificial insemination is common when developing different strains that would not otherwise be able to reproduce. Nothing to do with boredom.

If a randomly produced male lyretail occurs, it cannot breed because its reproductive organ is too large to be compatable with a female, so it would be a rare thing to even have a lyretail. By using artificial insemination, the commercial breeders are increasing the 'rare' thing to make it more common, to be able to sell more.

I do not like artifically created strains due to the relative unhealthiness of some strains. I've only bought oddball fish from those that either collect from the wild or that have been bred in a hobbyists' tank, rather than a common fish bred commercially. To think what has happened to the poor neon tetra... :(
 

no.1chuy

Large Fish
May 22, 2009
272
0
0
Las Vegas
#10
Feb 27, 2009
4,395
0
36
#16
Didn't mean to offend. Just wanted to point out how this fish came about. It is not uncommon in the commercial breeding of fish to do this sort of thing. I was not suggesting that a hobbyist do this (in fact, I am against it ethicly).

If you get a male lyretail swordfish, this is how it was created. He cannot breed. If you get a female lyretail, she ws also created this way, but she can be bred to a normal tail and produce lyretail offspring.
 

stoddern

Large Fish
Jul 26, 2009
153
0
0
Vermont
#18
same thing goes for dog breeds, most of the pure breds are a hundreds of years of selective breeding giving certain breeds wierd issues like dalmations go crazy in old age or rotties all have bad hips and like my poor golden lab/ golden retriever mix (she came from pure breed parents) got bone cancer which the vet told us is genetic for both lab and retriever of the golden variety.

not to mention all the genetic play with food, you guys like your fresh firm tomatoes? well to get them to make it from the field to the store they have been crossed with a gene from a jellyfish to prevent bruising. but damn are they tasty and really juicy hahahaha
 

Newman

Elite Fish
Sep 22, 2009
4,668
0
0
Northern NJ
#19
I know, those are more commonly known things. We were talking about swordtail genes, lyretails in particular.

Then its kinda different with a dig or vegetable breed rather than a fish breed. Idk maybe because it smaller and harder to do stuff artificialy.