knife in 20gal?

Orion

Ultimate Fish
Moderator
Feb 10, 2003
5,803
3
38
Kentucky
www.thefishcave.net
#1
I have never had a knife fish but was pondering the idea of mabey a black or brown knife fish for a 20 gal long tank that I recently got. It has plans to be heavily planted, and the only other tank mates would be an angel, blue ram, rainbow shark, and a 6" pl*co.

I have read that knife fish dont like high light, but with good places to hide would they be ok in a high light plant tank?

Any ideas welcome.
 

fishboy

Superstar Fish
Oct 22, 2002
1,565
0
36
34
Cincinnati, Ohio
#2
High light= bad for knife fish. They are primarily nocturnal creatures, and you probably will not see him that much in the day. You could still however keep him in a plant tank, just put many, many dark caves. Those tankmates sound fine, although it does look a little crowded IMO. Although they are very peaceful,I would hesitate though on the angel, because i have read that knife fish will attack angels for no apparent reason, and kill them. I would be on the safe side though and count the angel out. You should feed them live or frozen worms, and not keep more than one in a tank. They grow extremely large in tanks, upward to about 26" inches so be warned he will outgrow you tank.

Good luck,
Daniel
 

fishboy

Superstar Fish
Oct 22, 2002
1,565
0
36
34
Cincinnati, Ohio
#4
I don't think so, even in captivity they still would probably get somewhere around a foot. So i dunno. Most sources say though that they can get up to 2'. I'd say with good care the smallest a black ghost knife would get would be 15 inches, smallest.
 

adamj

Large Fish
Feb 21, 2003
419
0
0
Visit site
#5
Black and bowns get no more than 8 inches in an aquarium, they only get larger in the wild. you might be confusing black and browns with clowns fish boy.

Knife fish can choose to attack anything they choose to, but fish of a similar size are probably not going to be messed with. Similar sizes and bigger are just not on the menu for knifes feeding habbits. Im not saying a knife attacking a similar size fish is impossible, im saying its improbable. The only agression toward similar sized fish i've seen is when knifes are placed in new tanks and they will run off other fish to , in essence, establish a pecking order.

Knifes are nocternal creatures with an instinct for ambush hunting, so yes, they like the night. however they DO in fact come out redily during daylight hours and can be easily trained to eat during the day, even hand fed life foods, which i have and are doing at the moment with a small clown knife.

Yes, you will see them out in the evening, thats a given, but strong plant lights have no visible negative effects on knifes.

They do best in heavily planted tanks given their natural environments. This also caters to their ambush predator nature.

These fish can be kept with a number of other species, and are fairly gentle creatures. I've kept them with angels, goldfish, labyrinth fish, pleco's, snails, sharks, etc. They will defend themselves if attacked however.

They are predators, so they require life foods. I have trained some to grab at flake, however that should not be a staple food. Mine do great on a diet of frozen brine in chunks and life guppies and minnows on occasion, which i only add in while the tank lights are off simply to cater to the instincts of the fish, however they will hunt while lights are on, they are opportunistic in fact.

I hope i've dispelled a few old wives tales about knifes :)