Lake malawi tank....salt?

AVenom

Medium Fish
Sep 15, 2005
94
0
0
#1
So a good friend of mine is really into fish, and he suggested to me that I should add 1 tbls of aquarium salt to my tank once a month.
He said that these are not salt water fish, but there is some salt in lake malawi...I can't remember what he called it...something with a B..lol
Does anyone do this?
 

JWright

Superstar Fish
Oct 22, 2002
2,192
7
0
40
Snowy Upstate New York
www.cnytheater.com
#4
It's a very bad idea to add salt "once a month".

Salt is only removed by water changes. If you want to maintain a certain level of salt (really only useful in treating illness), you need to add a given amount per gallon initially, and then only add enough salt to replace what you take out during a water change. For instance, if you want to have 1 tsp per gallon in your 20 gallon tank, you would initially add 20 tsp. Then , when you removed 5 gallons for your water change, you would add 5 tsp of salt. Now, you might end of putting 6 gallons back in, but remember, that extra gallon is due to evaporation, and salt doesn't evaporate out with the water.

All that being said, adding salt long-term isn't going to help your fish any. "Salt" is a very generic chemical term refering to a wide varitey of compounds. It's true that the Rift Lakes do have a higher concentration of some salts in them, but that's not the same thing as having a higher concentration of Sodium Chloride (NaCl), which is all most "Aquarium Salt" is (same as table salt). Now, you can purchase salts that mimic the salts in the rift lakes, but those mixtures are really more useful as pH buffers. If you have soft water I'd reccomend it, but not otherwise.
 

JNevaril

Large Fish
Jul 10, 2005
369
1
0
42
Lincoln, Nebraska
#6
Hmm.

I thought I replied to this.

apparently not.

ANYWAY.

Kent's makes a product called Liquid Cichlid Chemistry. It will replace potassium, magnesium, and sodium 'salts' that are found in lake malawi, also replaces minor and trace minerals.

I use it.......my fish really brightened up......but it could also be the different light that i put on their tank too.

It's really your call, it's not necesarry, and it may help.....

Aquarium salt (READ: EPSOM SALT) is bascially a medicinal treatment......not the same as 'Cichlid Salts'

:)
 

wayne

Elite Fish
Oct 22, 2002
4,077
3
0
#7
I would agree with using a proper rift lake buffer rather than trying to bodge it with varying amounts of marine salt.
Poeple used to do that to help keep the pH up before realising hard water didn't mean brackish