Over Skimming ???

strout

Superstar Fish
Dec 21, 2008
1,009
0
0
#1
My zoas growth is very low, the polyps couldn't look any better, big and beautiful, just not very many babies, some frags none, some one or two. I have had my hands in the tank alot lately tearing the live rock apart catching unwanted fish, and I am sure this didn't help, but the problem has been going on much loger than that. Water temps are fine around 8o. I am only doing water changes every 2 1/2 weeks now, was doing them every week and figured out my zoas didn't like that and look much better now with less water changes. For a refresher: 125g tank, MH lights and T-5 lights (2 blue two white) The MH and T-5s over lap just a bit on their coming on and going off stages. 200g octopus skimmer, running GFO and Carbon 24 7 also. Flow in the tank isn't good enough for an SPS tank, but good enough for my soft coral, recordia, zoa tank. At one point I was starting to turn my skimmer off 2 days and running it the third day, but the RBTA didn't like that and started moving around the tank, so I started running the skimmer 24 7 again. The RBTA got into my power head and got chewed all to pieces and I never did go back to skimming 1 skipping 2. Skimming is the only thing that I can think of that might be the problem. I used to lose a frag of zoas every so often to melting when when I first started, dosn't happen any more, the polyps get big and look great, just don't grow babies. I have one colony of some green polys, started out with 5 or 6, now I have about a 100 or more of them, have a frag of 9 Armor of Gods I got a year ago, still have 9. I have tried moving them around the tank and where I have them now they like and look the best, just no babies. Have a friend that has great growth and we have talked, the only differance, she runs no skimmer. Other frags I have also stay small.
 

Last edited:

TRe

Elite Fish
Feb 20, 2005
3,645
1
0
ft. lauderdale
#2
Not sure what the problem is but I doubt its over skimming.... Ive always had better result with better water quality and that goes for zoas aswell as SPS! Ive got a few frags that havnt done much in 8-9 months and than I have others that have multiplied by 10 in that same time frame... Whats your Cal/Alk? What type of flow do you have in your tank? How long have you been running carbon 24/7?
 

Newman

Elite Fish
Sep 22, 2009
4,668
0
0
Northern NJ
#3
i think some zoas just grow slowly. maybe theyve been propagated so many times by fission in the past that they slowed down for w/e reason.
and i use fission instead of fragging because i'm referring to their natural splitting and growing polyps.
 

quaddity

Large Fish
Feb 25, 2007
641
0
0
Mesa, AZ
www.myspace.com
#5
The rule is this. If it's a zoa you want to reproduce it grows super slow. If it's some plain brown looking one no one will buy it will be a weed ;)

I bought 4 nuc green palys on a disk about 3 months ago. When I sold it yesterday if finally had 1 baby.
 

strout

Superstar Fish
Dec 21, 2008
1,009
0
0
#6
I picked up some Oyster eggs yesterday and I am going to try and feed the tank about twice a week and see if that will help on the growth rate, am also going to try turnning the skimmer off again for a day or two at a time.
 

TRe

Elite Fish
Feb 20, 2005
3,645
1
0
ft. lauderdale
#7
I dont see turning the skimmer off helping with your problem.... Have you looked into vitamin C? I havnt tried it myself but I know people who claim to better growth when dosing Vitamin C.... Be careful with the oyster eggs not to polute the water :D