Protein skimmer 10G

[CoolWaters]

is this a good protien skimmer for a 10g? its the smallest i can fine...
i might not even get one but might think about if when i get my dream tank started.

Lees - Protein Skimmer

wat about this one?

PetSmart - Visi-Jet Protein Skimmer by Aquarium Systems

 

[KahluaZzZ]

better do a good water change every week than use it...
Assuming yo will have a light bioload and some live rock, you won't need any skimmer in a tiny 10g

 

[TheFool]

Both are junk. Buy a BIG bucket of salt, and do a 25% change every week. It'll do more thn any skimmer could achieve

 

[TRe]

i would have to agree... iv had my 10 gallon setup for nearly 2 years now no skimmer just water changes

 

[YahooFishKeeper]

i dont think either would do harm if you wanted the extra help, but either way, i think you still need to do weekly 10-25% WCs.

 

[dbacksrat]

i dont think either would do harm if you wanted the extra help, but either way, i think you still need to do weekly 10-25% WCs.

No the "skimmer" is just gonna eat up electricity and make noise. Better do what everyone else says and just keep up with those water changes.