skimmer opinions needed please

#1
I am in the market for a good skimmer.... I am checking out the Seaclone 100 and the Red Sea Prizm...The LFS ( whose opinions I trust) suggested the Seaclone for its reliability and simplicity in its design over the Prizm. I was just asking your opinions on either one....Ya'll got alot more experience in this area than I do.
Thanks,
Cindy
 

OCCFan023

Superstar Fish
Jul 29, 2004
1,817
5
0
36
New Jersey
#2
cinlnk said:
he LFS ( whose opinions I trust) suggested the Seaclone for its reliability and simplicity in its design over the Prizm.
Cindy
lol no offense to your lfs but seaclones are pretty much crap. If you do a search for them on here yourll read about some horror stories with leaking and the occasional fire if I recall correctly. How bigs the tank this skimmer is for? I would suggest a aqua-c remora if funds allow it but if not there are good brands for less. Like I asked before how bigs the tank?
 

wayne

Elite Fish
Oct 22, 2002
4,077
3
0
#4
Use the internet. You will find almost noone with anything good to say re: seaclones - they really are abject junk. If you want to get one and spend a lot of time modding it to work so-so that's great by me, I would rather buy something that worked to start with.
I am actually a satisfied prism user, and I will still NOT recommend one. I know what I am doing, and I think the prism can be made to work just fine BUT is very, very hard to tune to work properly. Very hard.


I don't know how much your lfs wants for a seaclone. Frankly you may as well buy a Remora, it's not that much more, and the 50 60 dollar difference is likely the difference between spending 180 on a skimmer that works and 120 or whatever on a bum skimmer that is worth zero really.

You might consider looking around for a used skimmer if cost is that big an issue. There are plenty for sale - I like ones from AquaC (remora) and the CPR bakpak. In Europe I like bargains from people like Tunze and Deltec, these are also very good, easy to setup skimmers.

As a newbie getting a skimmer to skim is one of your greatest challenges.

As a note if your lfs is really recommending the seaclone as a great skimmer it's time to stop listening to their advice.