Small effecient algae eater

May 30, 2008
292
0
0
Midland, MI
#1
Hi all, any suggestions on a small effecient algae eater? I want it for my 29g. I see BN and RN plecos stay smaller, anything else that stays small and does a good job at cleaning, and how well does the BN and RN clean?
 

FishGeek

Elite Fish
May 13, 2005
4,294
5
0
38
South Carolina
#2
The only efficient algae eater that I have ever owned has got to be the Oto. Not saying others wont do it but Otos are more efficient. It may be becuase Plecos are known for eating other foods that fall to the bottom too; where as, the Oto's diet is algae, with only an occasional few that munch of something else.
 

TabMorte

Superstar Fish
Jan 17, 2008
1,470
0
0
#9
If you get Ottos get at least four. In a tank that size I would actually go with 6 or 8.(hell I have 6 in a 10 gallon!). They are far more efficent little algae when they have a proper shoal, and they're far more active and social too that way.

With the exception of the Zebra species which is larger, they stay very very tiny. I count them only as 3/4" of fish towards my stocking. They make very very little waste as well.
 

May 30, 2008
292
0
0
Midland, MI
#10
Wow, that many!?! I like the idea of having action in the tank. Really, the only purpose for me to get one is to keep the tank clean. If it is aesthetically pleasing, that is a bonus. I only have room for 5 inches of fish in the tank, using the 1in per gallon.
 

TabMorte

Superstar Fish
Jan 17, 2008
1,470
0
0
#11
I'd grab 4 to 6 then. Be warned they're not the hardiest fish at first. Be sure to acclimatize slowly and keep an eye on your water perameters as the little guys can not tolerate Ammonia well. They're wild caught in south america and then flown up to here so by the time they reach your fish tank they're likely enduring their 6th or 7th water change in a week. I try and get them when they've been at the pet store for at least a week when ever possible. They're more settled and less 'jet lagged' then.

Once they're settled in a bit of fresh veggies (mine LOVE cucumber) once and a while (I shoot for once a week) will help keep them healthy and hale. I find they toughen up once they get into a stable environment.
 

FishGeek

Elite Fish
May 13, 2005
4,294
5
0
38
South Carolina
#12
If you are going to go with that many then you need to supplement feed them. There wont be enough in the tank to sustain them.I don't recommend it as its hard to keep them fed, but...

When you look to get them at the LFS look for ones with bellies that are more white verses grey. The whiter the belly the more healthy they are and obviously if they have a normal belly they are being fed and are eating.
 

joy613

Medium Fish
Mar 2, 2008
99
0
0
#13
I have 4 in my 29 gallon 3 are little fatties one is smaller but seems to be healthy. I give them an algae wafer about once a week but the rest in the tank likes them so they don't really get a lot of it. They do better with more than just one. I noticed the last time I had only 2 and one died the other only lasted another month.
 

TabMorte

Superstar Fish
Jan 17, 2008
1,470
0
0
#14
They're easy little guys to feed. An algae wafer every couple days. Some cucumber once a week. I've been keeping them for quite a while now and never had a problem. As I said I have a whole shoal of them in a 10G and little to no problems.

If you have real plants they'll nibble on soft bodied once now and then when there isn't enough algae for them as well.
 

FishGeek

Elite Fish
May 13, 2005
4,294
5
0
38
South Carolina
#15
The thing is ensuring that they get it when there is other fish in the tank. And with the fish that are in his tank its not a good idea to get too many. Your tank only has a Betta in it so you really dont know how they would do in a tank stocked differently.
 

TabMorte

Superstar Fish
Jan 17, 2008
1,470
0
0
#16
Well and the simese algae eatter babies that steal all the food from everyone but yes.
It's my vegitarian + betta tank though.

Added: If getting food to the thing is an issue though a bristlenose pleco or flying fox might be a better choice for that tank then though. All those fish can be kept alone and more actively fend for themselves.
 

Last edited:
May 30, 2008
292
0
0
Midland, MI
#17
I was looking at a BN pleco, but like the idea of having three ottos in the tank as well. I guess I will do some searching and see what are available in my area and prices for each. Sounds like either option will be good for me. My fish do like to eat, food doesn't last long in the tank.
 

TabMorte

Superstar Fish
Jan 17, 2008
1,470
0
0
#18
There's a wide variety of bristlenoses out there too. If you can hook up with a local aquatic group/forum you can probably find a pleco breeder/dealer that can get them reasonably cheap. I find if you can find a reputable local breeder you'll get higher quality, hardier stock.
 

FishGeek

Elite Fish
May 13, 2005
4,294
5
0
38
South Carolina
#19
If you want something for an algae problem then your best bet is an Oto not a Pleco. But if you want something just to help out if there may be some then a Pleco would work as it would also eat other foods so supplementing wouldn't really be needed, which is what I was talking about before.
 

brian1973

Superstar Fish
Jan 20, 2008
2,001
3
38
Corpus Christi, Texas
#20
My pleco's keep my tank algea free, I still supplement with wafers, they will occasionally eat the floating pellets. I dont have otto's, I personally dont care for them, to small and fragile for me. I am not sure why feeding the otto's would be such a problem if you were to drop the wafers in after the lights have been out for a few minutes, unless of course otto's are not active at night.