OK Someone (wise) please teach me (fast)! I'm tired of my kids' fish dying! And I need more info on pregnant fish too!
Short version:
For 3 yrs or so we've had a female Blue Gourami (originally bought to be companion to lone male BG, but he died 3 days later) and a Chinese Algae Eater. 2+years they were in a 10-gal tank. We found a good deal on a 30-gal tank (tank only) and about a year ago we went ahead and set it up and after cycling a month or so we moved Elvira and Tootsie (CAE) into their new home. All has been well until a month ago.
About a month ago we bought 4 platies to add to the tank. We floated them a few hours and then slowly intro'd the tank water into their bag... a few hours later they were all in the tank.
Within a few days one died.
Not sure why - but noticing poor color in Elvira (the one fish we were familiar with as to color changes) we got worried the new fish had brought in some parasite or disease. Bought some treatment (broadrange) tablets recommended by a friend who's had multiple fw tanks and all sorts of fish for years. Five days of treatment... all seems well.
One of the platies is growing lots faster than the other 3 - and we learn that one is female and the other 3 are male.
Went to petco in the city and looked over options for fry, etc. and came home with bushy plant thingys that you can position on bottom or float on top or attach to sides.
Bought a small live plant too.
Also bought a heater to make sure water temp stays more constant as winter's coming already.
Soaked and rinsed all new stuff and added to tank. Put in some stress coat after.
Discovered Tootsie dead the next morning.
Live plant was dug up and floating in pieces on top.
Removed Tootsie.
Removed all pieces of plant.
Watched tank closely next several days.
Noticed the remaining 2 male platies were constantly pestering the female platy... no matter where she hid. There are several places - plants, caves, logs, - to hide but they can get wherever she goes.
Decided to move her with some of the tank water (&plants and one cave) to a 1-gal acrylic container. Within a few minutes she calmed down and seemed to be happier.
Went out the next day and bought a 1.5 gal tank set up - with hood, light, air pump, filter, etc. plus gravel and more plants. Set it up using mix of water and gravel from 30-gal tank and the 1-gal container. Added plants and included one of the two floaty-bushy things. Gave it a few hours to get the water mixed well and settle things - then put her in it.
Hershey loves her new home - eats well - seems happy - and is still growing larger. We are noticing little black dots on her underbelly when we get the change to see it.
3 days after moving her we discover one of the males in the big tank is missing... a thorough search finds him dead near the same cave where we found Tootsie. I just realized they were almost in the exact same spot too! But maybe that's because it's good hideaway type spot.
It's been a week since then, and Elvira and Silver seem to be doing ok. The water is cloudy but that may be from taking out and replacing about 8 gals of it shortly after the last fishdeath. A new filter cartridge went in then too. I'm getting a mix of advice - some say take the fish out and completely clean the tank and everything in it; some say just change out the water and filter more often for a few times. I'm not sure what to even look for and feel like no one knows if the 2 remaining fish are well, will be ok, or will succumb to whatever it is. And no idea how to find out for sure.
We have no idea when Hershey got pregnant (before or after we got her, etc) and have been told and read platies are pregnant anywhere from 2 weeks to 2 months, so not at all sure what to expect there. And is it possible for her to be sick or in danger from whatever is going on with the big tank? I thought about doing a fresh tank for her but needed to move her pretty quickly. The plan for now is to put her back in the 30gal tank after she delivers the babies and let them grow in the little tank for awhile, then move them to the big tank too.
And now Elvira is the only big fish... should we keep it that way or get another blue gourami - the ones I've seen in petco are half her size now.
OH - any ideas on lifespans of these types of fish?
We'll also get some type of algae eater(s) again too - just not sure what or when right now.
I know it's a lot for a newbie - but thanks in advance for all your help!
Last edited: