What about otos?

Newman

Elite Fish
Sep 22, 2009
4,668
0
0
Northern NJ
#2
they should be fine. depending on what alage youre growing though, they might not be able to eat it, so be ware. they tend to eat things other than string, blue green, green spot and black beard algae.
 

#3
I've got a green algea on the back of one of my rocks, and a yellow algea that constantly grows on the front of my tank... I've read in a magazine that they are "fragile and difficult and shouldn't be used by a begginer"? It says on here that they are easy...?
 

FroggyFox

Forum Manager
Moderator
May 16, 2003
8,589
10
38
43
Colorado
#4
They are usually hardy little guys but I wouldn't put them in a brand new aquarium because the biggest struggle is usually getting them enough food. In an established tank that is pretty large...you will probably have success with them...they seem to really love the brown algae, if you have normal green algae is there a reason you don't have a pleco in your 70? most plecos do a really good job of cleaning up that green algae :)
 

#5
Ottos

Ottos are a fine litltle fish for helping control algae, but unless you have quite a few 6-8 in a 70 gallon tank they will be fighting a losing battle. the group of 6-8 plus a few pond snails, and some really attentive tank maintenance with about a dozen live plants, and maybe even a few red cherry shrimps and you should have your alage problem under control. Ohhh and never run your lights more than 12 hrs. a day :)
 

#6
Well as of now I have an apple snail, a bicher eel, 6 tiger barbs, one mollie (getting more soon), one cory (again, getting more soon), and 6-7 hatchet fish

I know the eel is a ticking time bomb, however, it is small at the moment, and I plan on returning it to a store soon, selling it, or putting it in my dad's pond once he gets it established.
 

stacic8679

Medium Fish
May 18, 2009
95
0
0
indiana
#8
I was always told ottos were hard to keep alive but I didn't have a problem at all. I lost one the second day but I don't think that was my fault. The others have been thriving. Haven't seen a big decrease in the algae though. I think it is more effective if you limit the amount of light.
 

hyunelan2

Large Fish
Jun 1, 2005
684
1
0
45
Near Chicago, IL
#9
I am currently trying Otos again, after having had them a few years ago. I find that BN Plecos do a better job of algae control, but sometimes they won't go pick algae off of fine leaves. The smaller Otocinclus seems to do a good job of that.

I bought four about 3 weeks ago for my well-established 46g planted tank. I think I have one, maybe two left alive. Same thing that happened last time I had them... they just didn't last. I've had no problems with any of the other fish in the tank that I bought about the same time, so I'm not sure. I'll probably buy another 4 from someplace else and see how they do.
 

bassbonediva

Superstar Fish
Oct 15, 2009
2,010
0
0
Northern Arizona
#10
To give you an idea of how hardy my "mutants" are...I have a female (I think she's a she) from my original group of three that I've had for almost six months who is now missing an eye and she is queen of the tank among the otos. Hard little bugger to catch, too. Not sure how she lost the eye, to be completely honest. I haven't seen her much since I moved them to the 46gal a couple of months ago, but once I got the other three (soon to be four once I take the one that died the day after I bought him back and replace him) she's been out in all her glory. I've taken to calling her Pirate Sue...all she needs is an eye patch!
 

Newman

Elite Fish
Sep 22, 2009
4,668
0
0
Northern NJ
#11
Otos will live if you keep your water free of ammonia, nitrite and nitrates below 20ppm, and a constant pH. As far as my experience with them goes. mine werent even acclimated properly (parent dumped them in w/o my permission.) clean water helps ;)
 

JRB__

Large Fish
Oct 24, 2009
285
0
0
Australia
#12
I am currently trying Otos again, after having had them a few years ago. I find that BN Plecos do a better job of algae control, but sometimes they won't go pick algae off of fine leaves. The smaller Otocinclus seems to do a good job of that.

I bought four about 3 weeks ago for my well-established 46g planted tank. I think I have one, maybe two left alive. Same thing that happened last time I had them... they just didn't last. I've had no problems with any of the other fish in the tank that I bought about the same time, so I'm not sure. I'll probably buy another 4 from someplace else and see how they do.
Maybe try introducing them slower, maybe even with a drip system. Worth a shot, great to have in a good group.
 

emmanuelchavez

Superstar Fish
Feb 22, 2008
1,370
0
0
#13
In regards to their fragility, you also have to keep in mind that the vast majority of ottos are wild-caught. So between the shipping experience, then being cramped into tanks that have almost no food for them, they're pretty weak when someone first buys them.

Like froggy said, they do better in established tanks.

But to repeat what OrangeCones said, first find the root of the problem, that'll solve your problem long-term.