9g nano fw stocking suggestions

MdngtRain

Large Fish
Jan 9, 2011
288
0
0
New England
#1
Hi All!
It's been just over a year since I had to sell my tanks before my move. I got a betta down here, an recently have found a nano tank that I will be doing up as a FW tank. It's a 9g with an additional 2-3g in the refugium area. (Though AqAdvisor calculates it at 15.5g with the dimensions given)
I think my dimensions are 16wx14x16h for the total volume and 16x11x16 for the living space. Do you have any suggestions for what I could put with the betta? This guy is a tad more on the aggressive side, so I would like to try to keep them to fish he wouldn't want to chase too much. (going to keep his little 1.5g around in case he needs to move back to a bachelor pad after I get other fish).

It will be a planted tank with white sand substrate and lots of hides (driftwood, rocks, caves, etc). I want to try to give the betta his own space, but also have others in the tank. Is there any fish that might work better with him? I really miss my glass cats, but this tank would be too small for them. There's a blue light with this tank also, so I wouldn't mind a few white fish to show off in the light... I was thinking of a pair of swords, but worry that the betta would fin-nip them too much.

I really like the look of the black neons, but I worry that they will get too big (at a max of 1.5"-2") to comfortably live in the tank. Could I do a shoal of 5 black neons, 5 black kuhli's, and the betta (black and yellow)? I'd like to get some color in there, but not sure which fish would work for that - maybe 5 neon tetras? I've had them before though, and would not mind trying something different. AqAdvisor isn't bringing up any warnings other than the betta being potentially aggressive and a jumper.

I thought about a dwarf frog, but would feel the need to add a live-bearer or 2. I'm also not sure how well he would do with the betta. (this would mean no neons however, and likely no loaches)

Thanks in advance!
 

Newman

Elite Fish
Sep 22, 2009
4,668
0
0
Northern NJ
#2
I'd do corydoras catfish personally. sterbai are cool
bettas dont like small fish they can eat or similar sized colorful fish like guppies.
harlequin rasboras should be ok though as would jumbo neon tetras.
black neons are not too big, but you just dont want more than 4-5 of them.
 

FreshyFresh

Superstar Fish
Jan 11, 2013
1,337
23
38
East Aurora, NY
#6
Yeah, 9g is small and male bettas are all different. I had one that got along great with 4 zebra danios. Another that was Mr. CrankyPants and hated anyone in with him. Best bet in 9g is just keep the male betta.

My experience with bettas, both male and female is they won't leave shrimp or snails alone either.
 

Newman

Elite Fish
Sep 22, 2009
4,668
0
0
Northern NJ
#9
that group thing is overrated tbh for cories. i have seen one be real nice in a 6 gal and it grew huge. i have seen groups of 3 work great. ideally yes they like being in big groups but even with 7 panda i used to have they usually hung out in pairs or threes. rarely did all 7 congregate.

4 should work out great! because 5 would be overstocked! haha
 

MdngtRain

Large Fish
Jan 9, 2011
288
0
0
New England
#12
that I do not know... I know the quality sucks though, and I have to make sure it's safe before I add the fish. There's all sorts of chemicals in our water, so I was actually thinking of buying RO water at an lfs...
 

Newman

Elite Fish
Sep 22, 2009
4,668
0
0
Northern NJ
#14
yeah just use Prime. 2-3 drops per gallon is usually enough.

it's kind of important to know your pH, GH, and KH before you choose your fish.. if you cannot test those, have your local fish store test your water for you.
 

MdngtRain

Large Fish
Jan 9, 2011
288
0
0
New England
#15
I've never had a problem with the pH of my water and any fish I put in unless it fluctuated wildly. I would love to get a liquid test kit again, but it's just out of budget at the moment. I will take a sample to the store with me today to check parameters (thought they only use the test strips).
I grabbed some prime yesterday while I was out since I ran out of the conditioner I had before. It was easy to talk my wife into the extra $3 when I told her the bottle would last all year with this size tank ;)
Also, city water in south florida is some of the worst in the country. They are constantly putting up "boil water" advisories for random zones. I forgot how bad it gets here. I think it has something to do with the depth of the water table... I know several local beaches that get closed almost monthly because of the bacteria levels (though that is due to the sewage run-off they release near those beaches)... it's the same for fresh water. It's very sad, but I won't get started on my rants about protecting the environment here.

On another note, my betta acts like a puppy. He seems to make a game of swinning through the smallest spaces he can fit. He tests out each crevice, then will swim back and forth between the "refugium" and the main tank (he found the overflow hole). He will also "dare" the shrimp into a chase. At first they would scoot away from him in true shrimp fashion. They have since figured out that (like a puppy) if they don't run from him, he gets bored and gives up. He will stare down the shrimp, but if they stay put, he swims off. If they jump, he chases... I think he has spent too much time watching our puppy, lol!
 

FreshyFresh

Superstar Fish
Jan 11, 2013
1,337
23
38
East Aurora, NY
#16
Yep, bettas love to squeeze themselves in/through things as they're scoping things out. Mine always freak my kids out because they love to mash themselves in the plants or rest atop of the plants such that they're partially out of the water in my 55g. As soon as you approach the tank they dart right over to you.
 

MdngtRain

Large Fish
Jan 9, 2011
288
0
0
New England
#17
I have yet to see this guy "rest" anywhere except after lights-out. During the day, he's all over the place. In the past, I have had some active bettas, but none as active as this guy. He's really fun to watch.