I have a rubber-lipped pleco who gets a wafer about once a week, sometimes he is all over it and won't let my other fish near it and other times, he looks at me as if to say " yeah and???" and leaves it for my platy's to eat. I think most of the time it's really whether or not they're hungry. I also try to feed him at night after the lights have gone out, it keeps the other fish away from it, and it's when he's most active. I do make sure that I supplement his diet once a week with veggies though (Sunday night treats!!!), like romain lettuce (his favorite) or cucumber/zuccini. Maybe he's just not hungry?? How often are you feeding him the wafer?